• Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
info@olentium.com | +356 79048338
  • 0Shopping Cart
  • Home
  • Shop
    • Fragrance
    • Spa Skincare
  • About
    • About us
    • Eco-luxe ethos
    • FAQs
  • Journal
  • Contact
  • Menu Menu

Natural vs Sustainable Perfumes – which are better?

Buy & Wear Perfume
Natural vs Sustainable perfume

Natural perfumes and sustainable perfumes are often used interchangeably, but they are not the same thing. There is a lot of confusion about the numerous terms used in brand taglines and marketing copy to denote a natural cosmetic product, and understandably so. As there is no legal definition of the word natural on personal care products, although the ISO (International Standardization Organisation) has its version, cosmetic brands can pretty much get away with saying what makes commercial sense when using ‘natural’ and ‘sustainable’.

Natural perfumes may be labeled as “organic” or “all natural,” while sustainable perfumes may be labeled as “sustainable” or “eco-friendly.” Of course, if a brand is claiming organic status or aiming to comply with accredition schemes such as COSMOS organic, Natrue, and similar, then it must have undergone rigorous vetting of its products to allow it to use those bodies’ labels. However, natural and sustainable are almost impossible for the consumer to determine even in these days of heightened buyer power and transparency.

If we don’t know what we are buying, there is no way we can determine if a natural is better than a sustainable perfume. And we have to contend with greenwashing that is rife in the beauty sector.

So, let’s start with a few facts and observations.

Natural and sustainable defined

Natural perfumes are perfumes that are made using only natural ingredients, such as essential oils extracted from plants and flowers. We can use the ISO 2013:9235 definitions of aromatic raw material to judge natural. Sustainable perfumes, on the other hand, are perfumes that are produced in a way that is environmentally and socially responsible. This latter definition already takes us into vague territory. Who is the arbiter of socially responsible, for example?

One key difference between natural perfumes and sustainable perfumes is the ingredients used. We expect a perfume defined as natural to be made entirely with only natural ingredients, while sustainable perfumes can be made with both natural and synthetic ingredients.

But where do nature-identical ingredients sit? These have the same chemical makeup as their natural counterparts but are synthesised from other chemicals and/or botanical extracts. Hedione, which is a componont of jasmine, is one such nature-identical chemical. It is used extensively in perfumery to give radiance especially to white florals. It is far cheaper to synthesise than extract from jasmine but do you wish to accept it in a natural perfume? These are decisions the perfumer, brand and knowledgable consumer has to make.

Again, we have grey areas to contend with. At Olentium, we feel at ease with nature-indentical raw materials so long as they are not derived from petrochemical or the extraction industries, and are created in line with ‘green chemistry’ and are biodegradable.

For more on what makes a perfume natural, see our other posts:

Exactly what is a natural perfume?

Is natural sustainable?

how sustainable are natural perfume ingredients

Let’s point out at this stage that if you read the safety data sheet of a pure, natural oil – say rose oil – it will likely have a section showing that the material is harmful to aquatic life with long lasting effects. This is taken to mean in its neat concentration. As chemists will tell you, any material can be toxic, depending on the dose.

The fact is that a pure, natural perfumery oil such as rose may well be natural, but can be harmful in ways that may not occur to perfume consumers. Take for instance field upon field of damask roses growing in Turkey or Bulgaria. They seem the epitome of natural and nature doing its thing.

However, the fields of roses are a monocrop and squeezing out biodiversity. The roses are picked at dawn as that is when they are the most fragrant and undamaged. This removes the rose heads just as they are opening and so deprives insect life of their food source. Could those fields of roses produce much-needed agricultural crops? Perhaps.

With land use so pressured as climate change wreaks havoc on once fertile areas, it is likely we will get our minds to accept us eating lab-grown “meat” and other foods. So, when it comes to perfumes, which are a luxury not a needed daily personal care item (though we love using them!), there is even more of an argument to say let’s be content using synthesised ingredients if they prove more sustainable.

As you can see, there is no simple rule to state that natural is better when we assess the effect of the growing, harvesting, manufacture and transport of botanical ingredients on the sustainability of the planet. We did a deep dive on these issues in this post:

How sustainable is your natural perfume?

The expense argument

Natural ingredients, such as essential oils, can be more difficult to extract and process than synthetic ingredients, which can make natural perfumes more expensive to produce. In addition, natural ingredients can be less stable and more volatile than synthetic ingredients, which can affect the longevity and strength of a natural perfume.

Sustainable perfumes that may contain a combination of natural and synthetic ingredients allow the perfumer to create a wider range of scents and to control more finely the stability and longevity of the perfume. A botanical perfume can also have radiance, sillage and longevity, but may need to be worked with heavier molecular materials such as you find in base notes to ensure it lasts. Working only with naturals is both wonderful and constraining. A single natural ingredient, like our rose, is complex (rose has around 400 known compounds in it). How naturals interact to benefit a perfume is almost unknown. Synthetic aromachemicals are more predictable.

Sustainable perfumes can also be made with ingredients that are sustainably sourced and produced in an ethical manner. For example, some sustainable perfumes are made with essential oils that are extracted using renewable energy sources, that are sourced from fair trade cooperatives or manufactured with green chemistry practices.

For more on the costs of naturals, see this article:

Why natural perfumes are expensive

The production argument

Another difference between natural perfumes and sustainable perfumes is the production process. Natural perfumes are often produced in small batches using traditional methods, such as steam distillation or solvent extraction. This can make the production process of the raw ingredients more labour-intensive and time-consuming, which can drive up the cost of natural perfumes.

Sustainable perfumes, on the other hand, can be produced using lab-synthesised ingredients that are more efficient such as modern distillation techniques or renewable energy sources. This can reduce the environmental impact of perfume ingredient production and make a sustainable perfume more affordable.

Natural perfumes can provide a more natural and organic, photo-realistic scent, while sustainable perfumes using mixed media aromachemicals can offer a wider range of scent nuances, perhaps greater performance in terms of longevity and sillage, along with lower prices.

In addition to the ingredients and production process, both natural perfumes and sustainable perfumes come together when we address their packaging. Both can be packaged in recyclable glass bottles and in a more sustainable manner, such as using recycled materials or biodegradable packaging. The packaging is not a differentiator and as consumers we need to look carefully at our chosen perfume brand’s use of and commitment to sustainable packaging.

In conclusion, is a natural perfume better?

We have made only a few points here to show that this is a nuanced debate with many grey areas. Suffice to say that the issue is not about natural vs sustainable but how perfume per se, irrespective of its ingredients, can be sustainable. It is not an either or situation. We need to assess a perfume’s impact on the planet not based on whether it is all natural or not, but on how it harms the planet.

This is not easy for perfume consumers to find out and a lot rests still on the transparency and honesty of a perfume brand and its ability to truly work to measurable, third-party verified, sustainability goals. Natural perfumes and sustainable perfumes made of synthetics and/or botanicals can both be good options for consumers who want to support sustainable practices and reduce their environmental impact.

At Olentium, we work with mixed media, erring on the side of naturals. As a small, artisanal brand, we stive to do our due diligence on our suppliers and source from respected natural and aromachemical firms such as Robertet, Payan Bertrand and Albert Vielle for naturals and IFF and Firmenich for synthetics. The large fragrance chemical firms are able to pioneer greener production methods and invest in sustainable plantations of botanicals and promote ethical labour practices and fair trade. We work hard to know the provenance of our materials, try to use fewer, and source from nearer to home.

We never compromise on quality, and whether natural, synthetic or nature identical, we source the best. You can see our ethos outlined here. Some  natural brands you might like to explore are covered in our article:

Natural perfume brands at Pitti Fragranze perfume fair

11 December 2022
https://olentium.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Natural-vs-Sustainable-perfume.png 500 900 Liz Grech https://olentium.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/logo-olentium.svg Liz Grech2022-12-11 14:59:512022-12-11 15:03:01Natural vs Sustainable Perfumes – which are better?
You might also like
buy botanical perfumesHow To Enjoy & Sample Botanical Perfumes
how to make perfume lastHow to Make Perfume Last Longer
is perfume sustainableHow Sustainable is Your Natural Perfume?
How to choose your wedding perfumeHow to choose your wedding perfume
Benefits of botanical oils in skincareThe Benefits of Botanical Oils in Skincare
Best Mediterranean summer perfumesBest Mediterranean Perfumes for the Scent of Summer
Guide to perfume strengthsThe complete guide to perfume strengths
Best botanical notes for spring perfumesTop 10 Best Spring Perfumes
0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Mediterranean Sea Salt in Spa Skincare
  • The Benefits of Botanical Oils in Skincare
  • Borage Seed Oil Benefits in Skincare
  • Natural vs Sustainable Perfumes – which are better?
  • Citrus notes in fragrances

Categories

  • Buy & Wear Perfume
  • Fashion
  • Natural Skincare
  • Perfume Industry
  • Perfume Notes
  • Perfume Resources
  • Perfumes
  • Travel & Perfume

@Olentium

Sharing some love in the time of citrus and for Va Sharing some love in the time of citrus and for Valentines. 
To mark January's close of the winter citrus season here in Malta, and Valentine's Day, you can enjoy a 15 % special discount on Olentium 50ml EDP and 15ml French Flacon Parfum. Just use code: LOVEFEB on checkout*. (Sidenote: our perfumes ship with a 2ml tester vial.)
Olentium Le Parfum, a Mediterranean scent for everyone. A citrus-aromatic-amber fragrance with notes of lemon, mandarin, bergamot, myrtle, basil, ginger, orange blossom, cypress, amber and musk.
*Code is valid for single use only until 13th February.
Things are in the making at Olentium. With spring Things are in the making at Olentium. With spring in mind, we're in the mood for some Mediterranean spa self-care. 
All to be revealed in a couple of months....
It's winter citrus season in the Mediterranean. Wh It's winter citrus season in the Mediterranean. What a fabulous way to start the year with zing. 
We couldn't describe Olentium Le Parfum in a better way. Thank you @Letty114 for the review of our signature scent. As you say, it's an ode to the citric splendour of our Mediterranean island and our neighbour Sicily. 
Olentium Le Parfum is the ideal Valentine's fragrance as it was created for anyone who is in need of some Mediterranean vibe in winter.
Wishes for a wonderful start to 2023! Sincere than Wishes for a wonderful start to 2023! Sincere thanks to our clientele, followers and friends who have been so supportive of the Olentium journey as we took our first steps mid last year.
I wish you a day to rest and reset, restore and rethink so you can see your dreams, whether small or big, be fulfilled this year.
As to those resolutions, we are challenging ourselves to bring greater sustainability into Olentium. There are exciting plans to share with you.
Chiaroscuro of Mediterranean winter light. Palm sh Chiaroscuro of Mediterranean winter light. Palm shadow on perfume. Setting the scene for a crisp, bright citrus scent.
Citrus notes are often thought of as defining spri Citrus notes are often thought of as defining spring-into-summer fragrances, yet the fruit itself is at its best in winter in my part of the world. Our Mediterranean citrus groves are heavy with ripe fruit now. 
With citrus one of the most misunderstood players in fragrance - often thought of only as a cursory top note rather than part of the main concerto that comprises a fragrance - it's time to deep dive into the vast array of citrus notes. 
Citrus is the show opener and lingers well beyond top notes in our own signature scent - Olentium Le Parfum.
Our journal via bio link has a must-read for citrus lovers.
With the gifting season upon us, and perfume high With the gifting season upon us, and perfume high up the list of luxe to give loved ones, it's time to gen up on perfume strengths. Because when it comes to fine fragrance, it's not really size but rather strength that matters. 
Over in the journal, I've written a comprehensive buyer's guide to perfume concentrations. There's more to it than merely eau de toilette and eau de parfum. Head over via the bio link to read the knowledge.
Our little French flacons are strong and sensual. Our little French flacons are strong and sensual. At 25% parfum concentration, and in classic, glass-stoppered flacons, they are for making memories and memorable gifts this festive season.

Olentium’s perfumes and skincare are designed for self indulgence, sensuality and self-care. We create niche fragrances and luxurious, spa-style botanical bodycare from our base on a Mediterranean island

QUICK LINKS

  • Home
  • About
  • SHOP
  • SHIPPING & RETURNS
  • Contact

Join us for 10% off your first order.
Be first to hear about our luxury spa skincare launching spring ’23.

Thanks for subscribing to our newsletter!

Copyright ©2020-23 Olentium · info@olentium.com
Terms & Conditions · Privacy Policy · Disclaimer
VAT: MT1366-5908 · Phone: +356 79048338 · 14, SGW 1541, Malta (EU)

Citrus notes in fragrancescitrus notes in perfumeBorage seed oil benefits in skincareBorage Seed Oil Benefits in Skincare
Scroll to top

15% off Olentium Le Parfum for Valentine's! Use code: LOVEFEB at checkout | SHOP NOW Dismiss

Manage Cookie Consent
We use cookies to optimise our website and our service.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}